Cosmopolitan has led the women's glossies market for 30 years. As
the mag celebrates its anniversary, Poppy Brech asks how it can prevent
its younger rivals from taking over.
If Sex and the City's Kim Cattrall were a magazine, she would
undoubtedly be Cosmopolitan. Both Cosmo and Cattrall (who plays raunchy
Samantha) share the same uninhibited-to-the-point-of-outrageous approach
to sex.
Cosmo has been at the forefront of women's sexual liberation for 30
years this week.
For many women, buying the first issue of Cosmo is a bit like losing
their virginity: a necessary and important rite of passage. The magazine
has helped their sexual development by providing naughty sex tips,
fashion specials and relationship advice.
But what does Cosmo mean to advertisers? By contrast to lads' mags,
where explicit content is occasionally a turn-off for advertisers, in
Cosmo advertisers piggy-back an intimate relationship between magazine
and reader.
Brands in the first issue included Helena Rubenstein, Boots No 7 and
Scholl. Advertisers in the 30th anniversary March issue include Gap,
L'Oreal and Ford.
Like any market leader, Cosmo's dominance of the women's glossy market
is constantly under threat. Traditionally it has had to look over its
shoulder at Marie Claire, but in the last two set of ABCs the IPC title
has struggled to give chase.
The arrival of Conde Nast's handbag-sized Glamour last year caused
serious upset in the August ABCs. When overseas sales were included,
Cosmo held onto its number one slot by 690 copies, but on UK newsstands
Glamour outsold it by 50,000 copies.
Starcom Media's Duncan Sillence believes Cosmo is likely to outperform
both Glamour and Marie Claire in this week's ABCs: "NatMags has never
spent much on marketing Cosmo but has established it as a market leader
by investing in the product."
But as Cosmo turns 30, how will it continue to retain its appeal and
ensure it is still on top in 30 years' time? We asked Carolyn McCall,
managing director of Guardian Newspapers and Fiona McAnena, chief
executive of Mediaedge:CIA, which handles media for InStyle
magazine.
VITAL SIGNS
Circulation and growth of Cosmopolitan Dec 1999 to June 2001
Circulation % increase % increase
(period-on- (year-on-
period) year)
June 2001 452,176 -1.7 0.5
December 2000 460,086 2.2 -2.2
June 2000 450,057 -4.3 -4.3
December 1999 470,280 0.0 -1.3
Source: ABC
DIAGNOSIS
Carolyn McCall
Cosmopolitan has held the number one slot for the past 30 years in the
women's monthly market and deserves to celebrate. It has been a best
friend to millions of young women when it comes to shopping,
relationships and sex. So many magazines have followed where Cosmo dared
to tread. It has never strayed from serving its core readers -
20-something females with an independent spirit who today it describes
as "fearless and fun".
Only now might Cosmo have a serious contender in Glamour. Cosmo has
never feared to expand with Cosmo Girl, Cosmo Shows and Cosmo eyewear,
but with competition fiercer than ever, it could be in danger of
diluting the strength of its brand.
Brand extensions need to be strategic and not about short-term return,
particularly with a media brand like this that provokes strong emotional
attachment. As Cosmo celebrates its 30th birthday, it is probably the
time to focus more on Cosmopolitan the magazine.
It will be good to see Cosmopolitan's promotional campaign enticing new
readers rather than leaving it to branded hairdryers and yoghurts.
Fiona McAnena
In a kinder, gentler world, when I was young and eager to learn about
life - that is to say, sex - Cosmo was my wise big sister. She knew it
all, and let me into her gang so I could grow up. We aspired to be
liberated, and Cosmo helped us feel as if we were. Nowadays, who needs
Cosmo? It's the classic marketing problem faced by all pioneering
brands: as the market matures, competitors appear to chip away at the
big central brand. Cosmo pioneered the liberated woman's read, with a
bit of everything. Now, if you want raunchy, More! does it better. Marie
Claire is more stylish, Red and She more grounded and realistic, Zest
more authoritative on health.
And Glamour's dip-into format suits better for 'a bit of
everything'.
In its heyday, Cosmo was authoritative, understanding, honest and
daring, and men read it for an insight into their woman's world. But
being smutty isn't daring, and the good writing and exploration of
women's issues has been replaced by a diet of sex and disaster that
trivialises women's issues instead of addressing them. Cosmo was and
could be great, but right now it's Ibiza Uncovered in print.
TREATMENT
McCall's medicine
- Focus on the core brand - Cosmopolitan, the magazine
- Develop new revenue streams for the magazine - Cosmo looks reliant on
health-and-beauty and classified advertising.
- Promote the strengths of the title as a highly successful
international brand.
- Develop associations with like-minded third parties.
McAnena's measures
- Remember what you stand for and make Cosmo woman a strong clear voice
- not a loud-mouthed ladette.
- If the desire for liberation has been replaced by the demands of
'having it all', then help us deal with the issues this raises.
- Refocus on what you're good at: get some serious writing in to balance
the Sex and the City feel.