The success of Procter & Gamble’s newest venture into the UK soft
drinks market, Sunny Delight, has shocked many adults who have tasted
the ultra-sweet liquid, and food experts who have criticised it for its
low juice content.
But it is difficult to argue with sales that have beaten the mighty
Coca-Cola in the past month, and equally impressive repeat sales. All
the evidence shows that Saatchi & Saatchi’s advertising slogan - ’The
great stuff kids go for’ - is right on the nose.
We shouldn’t be surprised that the drink is doing so well. Its success
underlines an essential truth about P&G: that when it sets its mind to
something, its years of marketing experience - Sunny Delight was
exhaustively test marketed in Carlisle for 18 months before its national
roll-out in April - and distribution muscle combine to give it a head
start.
Sunny Delight has three big selling points. First, it is cheap; at
pounds 1.19 for 1.5 litres it compares extremely favourably with other
juice brands.
Market leader Tropicana sells for pounds 1.99 a litre.
The reason that it is so cheap is that it isn’t a real juice like
Tropicana.
It is more like a squash, with a juice content of less than 5%. But
owing to its packaging and position in the chiller cabinet, shoppers
perceive it as a juice and buy it instead of other juice brands.
Sunny support
Second, it has been backed by a pounds 10m marketing support package -
the kind that only multinationals like P&G can afford. Besides TV
advertising, Saatchis has also created press and poster ads. The product
has also been backed by a significant amount of in-store promotion.
Third, it has achieved almost blanket distribution in multiples,
independent grocers, forecourt retailers and CTNs. The listings in each
shop tend to be large scale too, aided by the small shelf space that
each bottle takes up. P&G is a great believer in the Direct Product
Profitability (DPP) ratio, which equates product price to the amount of
space it takes up. Sunny Delight has a healthier than average DPP
ratio.
It is also thought to offer the retailers better-than-usual margins -
crucial to convince them to stock a product which competes with their
own-label versions.
Sunny Delight is the second food and drink product that P&G has launched
in this country, the first being Pringles. The snack brand has
experienced similar growth patterns to its new soft drink sibling (see
table) and is now the second-fastest growing brand in the Nielsen top
100.
New territory
Food and drink is a fledgling sector for the company. In Europe P&G is
far better known for its detergents and personal products. But the
success of both Sunny Delight and Pringles illustrates why the
Cincinatti-based fmcg giant is lauded as such a bastion of marketing
excellence. It also reflects the expertise of Paul Polman, P&G’s UK and
Ireland general manager, newly promoted to president of P&G’s US laundry
and cleaning business.
’Sunny Delight is a classic piece of marketing,’ observes Andrew Seth,
former chief executive of P&G’s arch-rival Lever Bros, and now
non-executive director of The Added Value Company.
’That it can come into a market which it doesn’t have much of a
background in and do so well should make its competitors feel humble.
They shouldn’t have allowed P&G to come in from left field.’
But although it looks from here as though P&G has conjured up an
instantly successful food and drink heritage, the company’s history in
the sector in the US shows its learning curve.
Over the decades P&G had acquired a disparate package of food
brands.
Its oldest, Crisco (originally a ’shortening’ product and now a cooking
oil), was introduced in 1911. It bought Duncan Hines cake mixes in 1956,
Folgers coffee in 1963 and introduced Pringles in 1972. By the early 80s
P&G had identified soft drinks as an opportunity sector, snapping up the
Crush and Citrus Hill brands.
But cracking the US food and drinks market proved difficult in the early
80s and, for a while, it looked as if P&G would abandon the sector. The
Duncan Hines brand struggled against Nabisco (it has now been sold),
while the Crush and Citrus Hill brands also failed to hit the mark.
The latter weren’t long for the P&G stable, and were sold off to Cadbury
Schweppes. That proved only a temporary hiccup, and by the end of the
decade Pringles had become P&G’s top export brand. In 1989 the company
bought Sunny Delight, at the time a small brand sold only in Florida and
Southern California. Since then, thanks to P&G’s marketing and
distribution might, Sunny Delight’s US sales have tripled.
The turnaround in fortunes for P&G in the US food and drinks sector
encouraged it to move in on the European food market in 1991, when
Pringles was launched.
For the first six years, P&G used Food Brokers to sell in the brand -
marketing and distribution was only taken in-house last year when it was
decided to roll out Sunny Delight nationally too.
Opportunity knocks
It is still not plain sailing in Europe. P&G is thought to be close to
selling its Valensina brand, acquired when it bought German drinks firm
Rolf H Dittmeyer in 1984. Sister brand Punica, a sports drink, has also
had patchy fortunes - a small-scale UK test market has now been
abandoned with no plans for a national launch.
But food and drink has been identified by P&G as a sector of opportunity
- part of its ’Breakthrough’ strategy of doubling its dollars 36bn
(pounds 22bn) turnover in the next decade. In a recent speech, John
Pepper, P&G’s chairman and chief executive, reminded the company’s
shareholders and observers of its well-established tactic of creating
global brands. He quoted Olean - the company’s revolutionary food
ingredient which causes fat to pass through the body undigested - as one
brand with global potential.
The company is now considering the feasibility of rolling out Sunny
Delight across Europe. It is thought that P&G prefers to pour all its
juice expertise into one brand, which accounts for the possible
Valensina sale.
Food and drink accounts for 11% of P&G’s turnover globally, but much of
this is concentrated in the US at the moment. If the company wants to
meet its ambitious targets for the next ten years we can expect it to
put even more effort into rolling out Pringles and Sunny Delight right
across Europe and beyond.
SNACKS SALES
Value sales 52 wks to May 97 52 wks to May 98 % change
(pounds 000s) (pounds 000s)
Pringles 75,237 99,878 32.8
Hula Hoops 69,876 68,266 -2.3
Walkers Crisps 426,556 412,558 -3.3
Quavers 63,296 61,019 -3.6
Golden Wonder Crisps 50,883 48,119 -5.4
Others 168,552 188,854 12
Total 1,655,465 1,686,877 1.9
Source: IRI