The Co-operative
The Co-operative

Adwatch Review: The Co-operative

LONDON - LONDON - Alasdair Graham, creative partner at Ogilvy Advertising, reviews The Co-operative commercial which had the tenth highest recall with the public in the Adwatch ranking for 30 September.

Another ad for the Co-op (it seems to be advertising rather a lot recently). Did it work for me? To answer that question I'll have to tell you about my dear old grandpa.

He called it ‘t'Op'. He needed a speedy abbreviation for the place because he talked about it a lot. He always shopped at the Co-op. His father had worked there, which entitled him to some kind of unoff­icial discount. It wasn't just about the money - he loved it, and so I did, too.

I think I still do. The rejigged des­ign for the shops feels uncluttered, fresh and light. The famous Co-op logo has been nipped and tucked without losing what has always made it distinctive.

The website gets the balance bet­ween honest and silly about right, promoting its irresistible lem­on cup cakes, together with its urgent desire to change the world.

The ad features a typical family in a typical house sitting down to a typical stir-fry.

Typically, the daughter is in her own world, listening to music on headphones. Dad has to text her - on her typically pink mobile phone - to let her know dinner's ready.

Even with the father doing the cooking, and the mother absent, it has a whiff of ‘OXO family' archetype about it.

The Scottish accent of actor John Hannah, who does the voice-over, allows him to rhyme the words ‘good' and ‘food'. Otherwise, in spite of all the chat, there's nothing remarkable.

I'm told about the free-range eggs, the responsibly sourced king prawns and the... well, I can't remember what else I'm told, but I suppose I wasn't listen­ing.

Oh, you can eat all this for a fiver - a fairly typical message in these recessionary times. M&S, Waitrose and others have been pushing it for some time, with far more impact.

Nothing much to make me go out of my way to visit the Co-Op to pick up some responsibly sourced ingredients to make a stir-fry; or anything else. Remember, I'm a big fan of ‘t'Op'.

This is a shame. The Co-op has almost never done anything typically. It has integrity, but its real strength is that it has the right to be my local shop.

There might be a Tesco around the corner, or what­ever flat-pack store has just been assembled; but it won't feel like it belongs in quite the same way as the Co-Op.

Apart from my own feelings, I know my grandpa would have prefer­red this sort of approach. However, despite all his affection for the Co-op, there's really nothing it could do that would get him to try a king prawn.